Should We Worry About Where Our Instruments Are Made?

Should We Worry About Where Our Instruments Are Made?

Turn over a guitar, look inside an acoustic, or inspect the back of a keyboard, and you will usually find a little phrase that can provoke a surprisingly strong reaction: “Made in…”

For some players, the next word is reassuring. For others, it immediately raises an eyebrow. There was a time when “Made in China” was widely treated as shorthand for cheap, inferior and best avoided. Similar suspicions have followed instruments from other manufacturing countries as production has moved around the world.

But is that a sensible way to choose an instrument today? Or are we allowing an old reputation to do our listening for us?

A country is not a quality grade

The first problem with judging an instrument by its birthplace is that a country can produce both very basic instruments and beautifully made ones. China is not one enormous factory with a single quality standard. Neither are Japan, Indonesia, the United States or anywhere else.

A factory building to the lowest possible price has a different brief from a workshop given the time, materials and budget to produce something exceptional. That distinction matters far more than the distance between the factory and your front door.

Cheap instruments certainly exist. So do disappointing expensive ones. A flag on a headstock cannot level frets, season timber or cut a nut slot.

Japan: a useful lesson in changing reputations

Japan provides perhaps the clearest reminder that manufacturing reputations can change. Rather than dismissing Japanese production as a cheaper alternative, many players now actively seek it out.

One famous name behind that story is Fujigen. Its own company history records the introduction of CNC routers in 1981 and an agreement with CBS Fender in 1982, when it began producing Fender and Squier guitars. These were not merely instruments that looked a little like an American design. They were instruments being made for the brand itself.

Fender’s Japanese production became an important chapter in the history of some of the world’s most recognisable electric guitars. Fujigen also builds instruments under its own FGN name, drawing on decades of manufacturing experience.

The lesson is not that everything Japanese is automatically wonderful. It is that yesterday’s supposedly cheaper manufacturing destination can become tomorrow’s badge of desirability.

South Korea: the factory behind the familiar name

A brand name and a factory name are not always the same thing. Some very familiar guitars have been built by specialist manufacturing partners whose names never appeared prominently on the headstock.

World Musical Instrument Co. in South Korea is a good example. PRS identifies it as the maker of the first SE Santana model, unveiled at NAMM in January 2001.

That is a particularly telling example: an American guitar company, working with a Korean manufacturer, creating a more accessible instrument associated with Carlos Santana. The overseas factory was part of the product’s development, not something that made the guitar illegitimate.

It also illustrates why the year and model matter. Production arrangements change. A fact about an early SE guitar should not be treated as a description of every SE made since.

Indonesia: PRS and the Cor-Tek connection

Indonesia offers another real-world example. In 2019, PRS announced a dedicated SE manufacturing facility on the PT Cort campus in Surabaya, with machinery and staff focused specifically on its guitars. PRS subsequently released another factory tour in 2022 showing the development of its Indonesian operation.

Cort, also known through the Cor-Tek name, is a major instrument manufacturer. PRS’s descriptions of the partnership emphasise process, training and quality control, rather than simply finding somewhere cheaper to put guitars together.

This matters because “made overseas” can suggest that a brand sends off a drawing and hopes for the best. The documented PRS relationship is rather more involved: a manufacturing partnership with attention to how the instruments are actually built.

That does not make an SE identical to a Maryland-built PRS. Different ranges can have different specifications, construction details and finishing processes. It does mean that “Indonesian” is not a useful synonym for “inferior”.

China: craftsmanship beyond the stereotype

China’s instrument industry is equally difficult to squeeze into a single stereotype.

Eastman’s Beijing workshops are a good counterexample to the idea that Chinese manufacture must mean anonymous, entirely automated production. Eastman describes its string-instrument workshops in terms of traditional European methods, with skilled craftspeople using chisels, knives and scrapers. Its guitar and mandolin production is also closely associated with its Beijing workshops.

Then there is Epiphone’s Qingdao operation. Epiphone’s published catalogue history records the establishment of its dedicated Gibson Qingdao factory in 2002, with Epiphone and Gibson personnel involved in equipment, training and quality-control planning. It is a longstanding example of a famous American brand investing directly in Chinese instrument production.

Nor is this only a guitar story. Yamaha’s Hangzhou operation manufactures pianos, piano parts and guitars, while its Xiaoshan operation manufactures and assembles wind instruments and marching drums. A familiar name on a piano or wind instrument can sit above a thoroughly international manufacturing network.

None of these examples proves that every instrument leaving China is excellent. They do show why dismissing Chinese manufacture as a category makes little sense.

Why can overseas manufacture cost less?

Labour costs are part of the explanation, particularly where instrument building involves substantial hands-on work. But “Asia” is not a single wage bracket, and costs change over time. Japan, South Korea, China and Indonesia should not be treated as economically interchangeable.

Scale also matters. A large manufacturer can spread the cost of machinery, training and specialist processes across many instruments. Nearby suppliers and bulk purchasing can reduce the cost of components and materials.

Raw materials, however, are not automatically cheaper simply because the instrument is assembled in Asia. Timber and hardware may travel internationally before the instrument is even built. The species, grade, drying, selection and sourcing all matter. An inexpensive instrument is not necessarily made from inferior wood, but neither does a factory’s location guarantee premium materials.

A lower selling price can reflect efficient production and lower overheads. It can also reflect compromises. The useful question is: what has been saved, and does it affect the instrument?

How American is an American-built guitar?

There is another complication: the place where a guitar is built does not necessarily describe the origin of every component fitted to it.

Suhr provides an unusually clear example. The California builder states that it sources woods and hardware from around the world. It has also documented changing its headstock engraving from “Made In U.S.A.” to “Lake Elsinore, California”, while explaining that its established building methods had not changed.

Suhr has specified Gotoh 510 bridges on models including its Classic Pro Metallic. Gotoh is a Japanese specialist manufacturer of stringed-instrument hardware. Here, Japanese hardware is a deliberate component choice on a California-built guitar, not an embarrassing secret.

Even component brands can have more than one manufacturing origin. Hipshot explains that its USA Ultralite bass tuners are machined, finished and assembled in the United States, with some small parts sourced globally, while its Licensed Ultralites are made by a manufacturing partner in South Korea.

Depending on the particular model, an American-built instrument can therefore include Asian-made hardware or other internationally sourced components. There is no responsible universal figure for how many: that requires a model-specific parts list and reliable information about each supplier. It would be just as misleading to claim that every American guitar is full of imported parts as to assume that every screw was made locally.

The other side: origin can still matter

None of this means buyers should stop caring where things come from.

You might want to support a particular country’s workshops, preserve a regional craft tradition, or buy an instrument with a direct connection to the place where its design developed. Heritage and provenance can be part of the pleasure of ownership. That is a perfectly reasonable preference.

Working conditions, environmental practices and supply-chain transparency are also worth asking about. But those questions need information about the actual company and factory. Neither a low price nor a prestigious country-of-origin label answers them on its own.

And premium instruments can offer real differences: more labour-intensive finishing, carefully selected materials, specialist construction or additional individual attention. The mistake is not paying more for those things. It is assuming the country name proves they are present.

Judge the instrument in front of you

For a player, the most useful examination is often refreshingly practical. Is the neck comfortable? Are the frets tidy? Does it stay in tune? Do the controls work properly? Does it sound and respond the way you want? Is there someone you trust to help with setup, servicing and questions afterwards?

A good setup can make an enormous difference to playability, although it cannot turn poor construction into good construction. Equally, an impressive specification sheet cannot tell you whether a particular instrument feels right in your hands.

At Music Bits Company, we would rather help you find an instrument that suits your playing than encourage you to shop by flag. Our in-house repairs and setups for most string instruments are part of that practical approach: instruments are things to play, maintain and enjoy, not simply labels to admire.

So, should we be worried?

Interested? Absolutely. Curious? Definitely. Automatically suspicious? No.

Where an instrument is made is one useful piece of its story. Who designed it, who built it, what they were asked to achieve and how carefully the result was checked tell us much more.

The sensible position sits between two extremes. Not every overseas-made instrument is a hidden masterpiece, and not every American or European instrument is automatically worth its premium.

Ask questions. Try the instrument. Look at the workmanship. Listen to what it does.

After all, your audience is going to hear the music, not the postcode of the factory.

 

If you’re looking for your next instrument, explore our acoustic guitars, electric guitars, classical guitars and bass guitars, or pop into Music Bits Company in Alford for a chat. Whether you’re taking your first steps or searching for a different sound, we’ll help you focus on what matters: an instrument that feels comfortable, sounds right and makes you want to keep playing, wherever its journey began.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.